Concerns are mounting over the future of farms, homes and community land as questions remain unanswered about a proposed estate sale affecting local livelihoods.
Councillor James Buczkowski has written to the Duchy of Cornwall raising “significant concern” about reports that farms and land within the Bradninch estate could be sold, warning that uncertainty is already affecting residents, farmers and the wider rural community.
In a letter dated Friday, March 27, James said he was contacting the Duchy in his role representing Bradninch and surrounding areas following reports about the proposed sale.
James said: “The manner in which this proposal has come to light has caused significant concern locally.
“Farmers, residents, and the Town Council have all expressed unease, not simply about the decision itself, but about the lack of clarity and engagement surrounding it.”
He acknowledged the Duchy’s longstanding relationship with the area and its right to manage its assets, adding: “I recognise that the Duchy has a long and historic relationship with Bradninch and that, as a private estate, you are entitled to manage your assets and make decisions about your portfolio.
“I also recognise that, for some tenants, the opportunity to purchase their holdings may be welcome.”
However, he warned that key details remain unclear and called for answers on several points, including which holdings are proposed for sale, the timeline for any changes, and what the plans mean for residential tenants and community assets.
James said: “At present, there remains considerable uncertainty within the community.”
He added that clarity was needed on “the future of community assets, including allotments, recreational land, and other facilities relied upon by local residents” and what support would be available to tenant farmers wishing to buy land.
The councillor also questioned how affordability would be assessed and how the proposals align with the Duchy’s stated aim of delivering positive social and environmental outcomes.
From a local perspective, he said the potential impact could be far-reaching.
James said: “The potential impact on tenant farmers, families, and the wider rural community is significant, and it is not yet clear how these impacts have been considered.”
He called for greater engagement between the Duchy, local representatives and residents, suggesting a structured meeting or briefing to allow concerns to be raised directly.
James said: “This could take the form of a structured meeting or briefing, ensuring that concerns can be raised directly and that accurate information is shared openly.”
He added that any changes should be handled with care and transparency, given the area’s history.
James said: “Bradninch has a unique and longstanding relationship with the Duchy.
“Changes of this scale should, in my view, be approached with transparency, care, and a clear commitment to the communities that have been part of that history for generations.”
He said he would continue pressing for answers and ensuring local voices are heard.
